Tank Troll said:
That is the roll of the infantry, it is not every on else's roll. It would not make sense for a hard Navy trade to train to do that. The test is the basic fitness level. If your trade or branch wants/needs some thing more then have at it.
This is actually a reasonably good test for the Navy as well as there are common activities that could use the same sort of motions.
Lift things up = general strength test, varies from storing ship, humping ammo (with kid gloves) and also general damage control type activities (dragging charged hoses, AFFF canisters, fighting floods etc)
Casualty drag = Oddly enough, people in the navy could get hurt to and need to be dragged out of an area (fire zone). They could even be in bunker gear with air tanks on. The difference is you can't go more then 20 feet without having to go through a watertight door and over a coaming. You may or may not be alone at the time, and odds are good they weigh more, but still.
sprints with jazz hands = Run ashore to the bars? Just a general aerobic/speed test.
Sure, we don't carry our stuff around ourselves but we are pretty reliant on our ship to stay floating and moving along, and train to do all these kind of thing as well. There may be better tests, but makes more sense to me then doing sit ups or push ups. The difference is that the ship
is our weapon, whereas infantry carries theirs. You need your crew operating properly for the ship to be able to kill people and wreck their stuff (or whatever the mission happens to be; could easily be saving people and fixing their stuff as well), and having a fit crew not making poor decisions due to fatigue is a good thing.
My only thing is that the standard is low enough that it's hard to fail, but the PT test really shouldn't be your only tool to combat obesity, and don't think that's the goal. All it is really supposed to do is give a baseline standard for the universality of service requirements, which it seems to do. :2c: