Fizzik said:
You will see the the problems this has created and will continue to create problems at places such as the Brigades being full of semi-trained no hook privates. It becomes an administration problem among many other imaginative scenarios. From my experience a lot of individuals once arriving at Brigade HQ&Sigs are then farmed out to other units in support which is a step in the right direction(more hands-on).
The hell it is. Maybe for the individuals themselves, sure. They'll be exposed to a lot. For the good of the service and units? Not a chance in hell. When you're a tradesman at a first-line unit, you're supposed to be the SME.
When this first originally rolled out, we were told an ACISS DP1 would be able to function out of the school as a basic CP Operator, with exposure to elements of the other specialties so that they would be familiar with the basics, to a point where they could receive OJT.
What I have found is distinctly different
Voice Procedure - atrocious. And I don't mean needs practice, I mean a complete unfamiliarity with proper procedure on nets, from the basics of a NCS initiated Radio Check, to no knowledge of Radio Reports and Returns.
Troubleshooting skills - almost nonexistent. Beyond recognition of brainfarts of "forgot to plug in the coax", the training they seem to have directs them as soon as they see error codes or something doesn't work, instead of using logical problem-solving process to at least isolate the issue, Find a Tech! When the techs ask what's wrong with it, the invariable answer is "It doesn't work". That or blank N/S tags.
Unfamiliarity with Equipment - I'm not talking about the kids showing up not knowing how to program new stuff, or how to set up DAMA with a 117. I'm talking about a kid not knowing how to attach the amp to the Radio. I'm talking about them not being able to setup an LDN to save their lives. I'm talking about them having never seen a Sputnik Antenna element before.
I brought this up during a town hall with the CFSCE Commandant a couple months ago when he came to visit us in the field. Brought up the fact that it's great that you spend 2 weeks at the school teaching them EPLRS and ECM, even though half of them don't do the training because they don't have the Sec Clearance, and nevermind the fact that EPLRS has not nearly been implemented in the field force, and they won't touch ECM. So instead of wasting time, why not focus on more of the basics. Answer I got "We've gotten that feedback. Which is why they'll get more line training".
I don't want to take away from the guys, they work hard, and they are eager to learn. It's not their fault that the School is pushing the Onus of training the basics onto the HQ & Sigs. It's not their fault that the HQ & Sigs are pushing these kids to first-line units. But that's what's happening, and it's bullshit. Virtualization of training + OJT + DL's is NOT the answer as a REPLACEMENT for proper training, but it's the answer we're getting in the trade, and it's going to bite us in the *** very, very hard. Like skin-grafting hard.
Want to decentralize training? Fine. Send out some standards to the Bdes, setup training troops, and run courses there. Unfortunately, Op Tempo and manning being what it is, we can't afford to do that.
What's the answer? My initial answer apparently isn't acceptable (I was NOT a proponent of amalgamation). So here goes. First off, the DP1 has to be rewritten. We've been told that the army won't allow any days added onto the training. Fine, then the time available has to be managed better, with the main focus being on the BASICS, taught to a sufficient standard.
To catch the stuff that these guys aren't learning, some sort of STANDARD OJT package has to be pushed out, much like the old QL4. And DP1's should NOT be pushed out to First-line units until they have at least completed that package.
Until then, we're going to get a lot of people falling through the cracks, and the trade is seriously going to suffer for it.