• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

The Threat of Modern Piracy- A Merged Thread

http://www.navytimes.com/news/2009/04/ap_piracy_update_040809/

Bainbridge arrives at pirate hijacking

By Katharine Houreld - The Associated Press
Posted : Wednesday Apr 8, 2009 21:47:43 EDT
 
NAIROBI, Kenya— In a riveting high-seas drama, an unarmed American crew wrested control of their U.S.-flagged cargo ship from Somali pirates and sent them fleeing to a lifeboat with the captain as hostage.

A U.S. warship arrived on the scene Thursday morning and was near the ship — the first with an American crew to be taken by pirates off the Horn of Africa — as crew members negotiated with the pirates for the return of the captain.

The owner of the Maersk Alabama, the American cargo ship seized Wednesday by Somali pirates, said the destroyer Bainbridge had arrived.

It was not clear what the military crews would do. Options could include negotiation, backed by the threat of force. But any military action could risk the lives of the Americans, especially the captain being held hostage.

Family members said Capt. Richard Phillips surrendered himself to the pirates to secure the safety of the crew.

“What I understand is that he offered himself as the hostage,” said Gina Coggio, 29, half-sister of Phillips’ wife. “That is what he would do. It’s just who he is and his response as a captain.”

Details of the day’s events emerged sporadically as members of the crew were reached by satellite phone, providing a glimpse of the maneuvering.

A sailor who spoke to the Associated Press said the entire 20-member crew had been taken hostage but managed to seize one pirate and then successfully negotiated their own release. The man did not identify himself during the brief conversation.

The crisis played out hundreds of miles off the coast of Somalia — one of the most lawless nations on earth. President Barack Obama was following the situation closely, foreign policy adviser Denis McDonough said.

The Maersk Alabama was the sixth vessel seized by Somalis pirates in a week. Pirates have staged 66 attacks since January, and they are still holding 14 ships and 260 crew members as hostages, according to the International Maritime Bureau, a watchdog group based in Kuala Lumpur.

Somalia’s 1,900-mile long coastline borders one of the world’s busiest shipping lanes and offers a perfect haven to the heavily armed pirate gangs. They often dress in military fatigues and use GPS systems and satellite phones to coordinate attacks from small, fast speedboats re-supplied by a larger “mother ship.”

The pirates usually use rocket propelled grenades, anti-tank rocket launchers and automatic weapons to capture large, slow-moving vessels like the U.S.-flagged 17,000-ton Maersk Alabama, which was carrying food aid from USAID and other agencies to help malnourished people in Uganda and Somalia.

According to reports from the crew, the pirates sank their boat when they boarded the ship. The captain talked them into getting off the vessel using one of the ship’s lifeboats.

Second Mate Ken Quinn told CNN in a live interview Wednesday that the crew also had held a hostage.

“We had a pirate, we took him for 12 hours,” Quinn said. “We returned him, but they didn’t return the captain.”

Maersk Line Limited CEO John F. Reinhart said his company received a call that indicated the crewmen were safe. But the call got cut off, and the company could not ask any more questions.

It remained unclear how the unarmed sailors could have overpowered pirates armed with automatic weapons.

Capt. Shane Murphy, second in command on the ship, told his wife, Serena, that pirates had followed the ship Monday and pursued it again for three or four hours before boarding it Wednesday morning, family members said.

The ship was taken about 7:30 a.m. local time about 380 miles east of the Somali capital of Mogadishu. Analysts say many of the pirates have shifted their operations down the Somali coastline from the Gulf of Aden to escape naval warship patrols.

Reinhart said the company’s vessels had received a heightened alert about piracy activity. He did not have particulars about how the ship was taken, but said the crew’s orders were to hide in safe rooms until aid came. They did not have weapons, he said, and typically, their defense would be to fight the pirates off with fire hoses as they climbed up the stern.

Andrea Phillips, the captain’s wife, said her husband had sailed in those waters “for quite some time” and a hijacking was perhaps “inevitable.”

Capt. Joseph Murphy, a professor at the Massachusetts Maritime Academy, said his son was a 2001 Massachusetts Maritime Academy graduate who recently talked to a class about the dangers of piracy.

The younger Murphy wrote on his Facebook profile that he worked in waters between Oman and Kenya.

“These waters are infested with pirates that highjack (sic) ships daily,” Murphy wrote on the page, which features a photograph of him. “I feel like it’s only a matter of time before my number gets called.”

Joseph Murphy said his son was trained in anti-piracy tactics at the academy and received training with firearms and small-arms tactics.

Piracy expert Roger Middleton from London-based think-tank Chatham House said it was unclear whether the pirates knew they were hijacking a ship with American crew, but the incident would strengthen the hand of those in American military circles who wanted to take a more robust approach to anti-piracy operations.

Multimillion dollar ransoms are fueling a piracy explosion. There were 111 attacks in 2008, and more than half that number have been occurred in the first four months of this year. Last year, pirates made off with up to $80 million in ransom money, said Middleton. Those hauls included payment for a Saudi oil tanker and a Ukrainian ship loaded with military tanks, both of which were later released.

NATO already has five warships in the Gulf of Aden and is planning to deploy a permanent flotilla to the region this summer.

The hijackings — and the resulting jumps in insurance fees and shipping costs — have prompted many countries to send their navies to the region. The NATO warships patrol alongside three frigates from the European Union, and up to ten American ships. India, China, Japan, Russia and other nations also cooperate in the international patrols.

U.S. Navy spokesman Lt. Nathan Christensen said the closest U.S. ship at the time of the hijacking was 345 miles (555 kilometers) away.

“The area the ship was taken in is not where the focus of our ships has been,” Christensen said. “The area we’re patrolling is more than a million miles in size. Our ships cannot be everywhere at every time.”

It’s a lesson the Somali pirates have taken to heart, venturing hundreds of miles offshore to capture a British ship, a Taiwanese trawler, a Yemeni tug, a German vessel and a French yacht in the past week.

In an interview with the AP, a man identified by villagers as a pirate, said his gang was not merely a band ruffians, but a well-organized, business-minded group that also had philanthropic concerns.

“We have leaders, investors, young people who go to the sea for hunting ships and also negotiators in many areas,” said the man, who identified himself only as Madobe. He said he was in his 20s.

Douglas J. Mavrinac, the head of maritime research at investment firm Jefferies & Co., said using U.S.-fagged ships with American crews was rare because of the high costs. But they are used to carry U.S. government aid.

There are fewer than 200 U.S.-flagged vessels in international waters, said Larry Howard, chair of the Global Business and Transportation Department at SUNY Maritime College in New York.
 
Seems about time boat crews start arming themselves. It would probably scare the hell out of the pirates if they started taking fire from the boat they were trying to capture. Although, maybe the reason they don't is they would be killed rather than just taken hostage.  :2c:
 
The pirates come from Somalia... a failed state that has been at war for night on 35 years.
Having someone shooting back at them would have little or no effect on the pirates... other than escalating the firepower & ruthlessness used by the pirates.
 
geo said:
The pirates come from Somalia... a failed state that has been at war for night on 35 years.
Having someone shooting back at them would have little or no effect on the pirates... other than escalating the firepower & ruthlessness used by the pirates.

That's just your opinion, and one that few likely agree with. Armed resistance has always been a deterrent for the bad guys. That's why an armed citizenry has a lower crime rate than those that don't. Criminals are cowards at heart and don't like being killed.
 
Rant Time! :rage:
Enough of making excuses for these "pirates". I could care less about "socio-economic" conditions or "psychological" excuses.
When someone tries to take your stuff by forcefully entering your home what should you do? FIGHT BACK!!!!
And if you kill them, they won't do it again will they? And this is recognized under law that you are acting in self defense.
Same applies here. Kill the pirates, problem goes away. Simple. :rage:
AM I the only one who sees this?
 
CTV's Update

U.S. warship arrives as pirates' options dwindle
Updated Thu. Apr. 9 2009 6:27 AM ET The Associated Press
Article Link

NAIROBI, Kenya -- A U.S. destroyer kept watch Thursday over the waters where Somali pirates held the American captain of a hijacked cargo ship that was later retaken by the crew in an hours-long, high seas drama.

The pirates took Capt. Richard Phillips as a hostage as they escaped into a lifeboat Wednesday in the first such attack on American sailors in around 200 years.

Kevin Speers, a spokesman for the ship company Maersk, said the USS Bainbridge had arrived off the Horn of Africa near where the pirates were floating near the Maersk Alabama.

"It's on the scene at this point," Speers said of the Bainbridge, adding that the lifeboat holding the pirates and the captain is out of fuel.

"The boat is dead in the water," he told AP Radio. "It's floating near the Alabama. It's my understanding that it's floating freely."

The Bainbridge was among several U.S. ships that had been patrolling in the region when the 17,000-ton U.S.-flagged cargo ship and its 20 crew were captured Wednesday.

Phillips' family was gathered at his Vermont farmhouse, anxiously watching news reports and taking telephone calls from the U.S. State Department to learn if he would be freed.

"We are on pins and needles," said Gina Coggio, 29, half-sister of Phillips' wife, Andrea, as she stood on the porch of his one-story house Wednesday in a light snow. "I know the crew has been in touch with their own family members, and we're hoping we'll hear from Richard soon."

Phillips surrendered himself to the pirates to secure the safety of the crew, Coggio said.

"What I understand is that he offered himself as the hostage," she said. "That is what he would do. It's just who he is and his response as a captain."

With one warship nearby and more on the way, piracy expert Roger Middleton from London-based think tank Chatham House said the pirates were facing difficult choices.

"The pirates are in a very, very tight corner," Middleton said. "They've got only one guy, they've got nowhere to hide him, they've got no way to defend themselves effectively against the military who are on the way and they are hundreds of miles from Somalia."

The pirates would probably try to get to a mothership, he said, one of the larger vessels that tow the pirates' speedboats out to sea and resupply them as they lie in wait for prey. But they also would be aware that if they try to take Phillips to Somalia, they might be intercepted. And if they hand him over, they would almost certainly be arrested.

"If I was a pirate at this point, I think I'd resign and take up gardening," Middleton said.

Other analysts say the U.S. will be reluctant to use force as long as one of its citizens remains hostage. French commandos, for example, have mounted two military operations against pirates once the ransom had been paid and its citizens were safe.

The Maersk Alabama, en route to neighboring Kenya and loaded with relief aid, was attacked about 380 miles (610 kilometers) east of the Somali capital of Mogadishu. It was the sixth vessel seized in a week.
More on link
 
And the naval standoff continues. Hopefully they'll be able to rescue the Maersk Alabama's captain soon.

http://ca.news.yahoo.com/s/reuters/090409/us/usreport_us_somalia_piracy

MOGADISHU/WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Somali pirates defied international naval powers on Thursday to keep an American ship captain hostage on a lifeboat in the Indian Ocean after their first seizure of U.S. citizens.


The increasingly bold gunmen briefly hijacked the 17,000-tonne Maersk Alabama freighter on Wednesday, but the 20 American crew retook control after a confrontation far out at sea, where pirates have captured five other vessels in a week.


Four gang members were holding the captain, Richard Phillips, on the ship's lifeboat after he apparently volunteered to be a hostage for the sake of his crew.


"What I understand is he offered himself as the hostage to keep the rest of the crew safe," his sister-in-law Gina Coggio told the ABC network. "That is what he would do, that's just who he is, and his responsibility as the captain."


The Pentagon said it was seeking a peaceful solution but was not ruling out any option in freeing Phillips.



His capture and the attack on his ship has once again focused world attention on Somali piracy, as happened last year when gunmen seized a Saudi supertanker with $100 million of oil on board, and a Ukrainian ship with 33 tanks.


Yet the attacks have been happening for years, reaching unprecedented levels in 2008, and pirates are holding more than 200 other hostages on captured ships.


Reached by Reuters via satellite phone, the pirates on the lifeboat sounded desperate as they watched a U.S. warship and other foreign naval vessels close to them. "We are surrounded by warships and don't have time to talk," one said. "Please pray for us."


The Danish-owned freighter's operator Maersk Line Ltd said Phillips was unharmed and securing his safe return was the firm's priority. The U.S. warship Bainbridge arrived on the scene before dawn, it added.


The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) said it had been called in to assist, and its negotiators were "fully engaged."


U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said the lifeboat now appeared to be out of fuel. An East African maritime group said the Maersk Alabama was on its way to Kenya's Mombasa port and would reach there in a couple of days.


The attack was the latest in a sharp escalation in piracy in the waters off lawless Somalia, where heavily armed sea gangs hijacked dozens of vessels last year and extracted millions of dollars in ransoms.


The Saudi and Ukrainian boats fetched about $3 million each.


The long-running phenomenon has disrupted shipping in the strategic Gulf of Aden and busy Indian Ocean waterways, increased insurance costs and made some firms send their cargoes round South Africa instead of through the Suez Canal.


The upsurge in attacks makes a mockery of an unprecedented international naval effort against the pirates, including ships from Europe, the United States, China, Japan and others, who are patrolling off Somalia, mainly in the Gulf of Aden.


PIRATES HOLD CAPTAIN AS "SHIELD"


Pirates say they are undeterred by the foreign flotilla and will simply move operations away from the patrols, further out into the Indian Ocean.

"The solution to the problem, as ever, is the political situation in Somalia," said analyst Jim Wilson, of Lloyds Register-Fairplay. Somalia has been mired in civil conflict, with no effective central control, for 18 years.

"Until there is peace on land there will be piracy at sea."

Maersk said its crew regained control of the Alabama on Wednesday when the pirates left the ship with the captain.

The ship was carrying thousands of tons of food aid destined for Somalia and Uganda from Djibouti to Mombasa, Kenya, when it was attacked about 300 miles off Somalia.

"We are just trying to offer them whatever we can, food, but it is not working too good," second mate Ken Quinn told CNN of efforts to secure their captain's release. He said the four pirates sank their own boat after they boarded the Alabama.

Then the captain talked the gunmen into the ship's lifeboat with him. The crew overpowered one of the pirates and sought to swap him for the captain, Quinn told CNN.

"We kept him for 12 hours. We tied him up," Quinn said. They freed their captive, he added, but the exchange did not work.

In Haradheere port, a pirate stronghold, an associate of the gang said the gunmen were armed and ready to defend themselves.

"Our friends are still holding the captain but they cannot move, they are afraid of the warships," he told Reuters. "We want a ransom and of course the captain is our shield. The warships might not destroy the boat as long as he is on board."

Pirates there said two boats full of gunmen had left the port to go and support their surrounded colleagues.

"We are afraid warships will destroy them before they reach the scene," one told Reuters.

(Additional reporting by Washington bureau and Daniel Wallis, Andrew Cawthorne in Nairobi; Writing by Daniel Wallis and Andrew Cawthorne, editing by Mark Trevelyan)
 
I was watching CNN this morning (I know, but there are more unbiased then the Canadian Media  ::)); They had an EX US Navy AJAG (what ever they call them) on, and he was saying that the Pirates holding the American Captive can be trailed in the US under International and US law.  He stopped just short of saying GITMO, but he implied it.
 
One answer to pirates--Peter Worthington of the Toronto Sun rather longs for older times (usual copyright disclaimer):

Hang 'em from the yardarm
http://www.torontosun.com/news/columnists/peter_worthington/2009/04/09/9061306-sun.html

The only thing odd about those Somali pirates who plunder the Indian Ocean, Gulf of Aden and Arabian Sea is how come they are still doing it?

One would have thought they'd have been exterminated by now.

But no, they're still at it. Not only that, they are alarmingly successful.

Over one weekend, five ships were hijacked -- merchant vessels from Britain, France, Germany, Taiwan and Yemen -- followed by the piracy of a British and a Taiwanese ship near the Seychelles in the mid-Indian Ocean.

What gives here?

There were some 130 piracy incidents in 2008 with 250 hostages taken (most still awaiting ransom or rescue, somewhere in Somalia). The world's navies seem incapable of halting this colourful way of earning a living, or extorting money.

News reports tell of a Canadian frigate's encounter with pirates
http://toyoufromfailinghands.blogspot.com/2009/04/sheepdogs-doing-what-sheepdogs-do.html
-- which may help explain why these brigands of the sea not only still exist, but seem to operate with impunity when confronted by the world's navies.

Apparently last weekend, HMCS Winnipeg, a frigate and a component of NATO'S counter-piracy mission (Operation Allied Protector) spotted three small pirate sciffs closing in on an Indian merchant ship (the Pacific Opal) in the Arabian Gulf.

Instead of demanding the pirates to surrender or be sunk, the Winnipeg's helicopter hovered between the pirates and the threatened vessel, and dangled a large sign over the side of the helicopter, alongside the chopper's machine gun, that had the word "Stop" written in Somali.

The news report quoted the Winnipeg's skipper, Cmdr. Craig Baines, as saying: "They got the idea that we don't like what they're doing," and the pirates called off their attack.

Surely peace and security and common sense would have been better served if the Winnipeg and its helicopter had given the crews of the three pirate sciffs a one way trip to Davey Jones' locker, and sunk them.

And then turned their attention to the pirates' mother ship, from which the three sciffs departed. At least the captain didn't apologize for interrupting their activities.

'RULES OF ENGAGEMENT'

Cmdr. Baines obviously was following NATO orders -- likely more "rules of engagement" that plague our soldiers and inhibit them from firing back unless absolutely necessary, and giving the benefit of any doubts to insurgents.

In the old days, pirates used to be hanged from the yardarm when captured.

It didn't stop piracy, but it at least eliminated pirates one at a time.

One of the prize ships captured by pirates was a Ukrainian tanker loaded with tanks and weapons -- of substantial interest to those who might want to purchase such items.

What puzzles me is why some adventurous young millionaire somewhere, hasn't shown the enterprise to outfit a torpedo boat disguised as a pleasure craft, and head for the Somali coast to lure pirates into attacking -- and then unloading on them with massive firepower.

It's hard to fault pirates for doing what they can get away with, but there's no excuse for letting them do what they do with impunity.

On an encouraging note, Associated Press reports that an American cargo ship hijacked last week -- the sixth such incident in a week -- has been re-captured by its 20-member crew, with the pirates "apparently in the water."

One hopes so, even if President Barack Obama feels it necessary to apologize for such "arrogant" American lack of consideration to pirates.

President Obama still isn't out of the woods yet, especially if the pirates do not face justice. But things are a whole lot better than when the pirates first had the ship.

Mark
Ottawa
 
milnews.ca said:

There are rumors that there was already a GSG9 Unit on it´s way to the region to free the captured german ship as there are some german citizens onboard. But it was called off when the ship entered an Somali harbour.

Regards,
ironduke57
 
The Captain tried to get away during the night but was recaptured. With only 4 pirates in the lifeboat I would think a SEAL action might be able to spring the man. Then you dont have to worry about jailing the bad guys. ;)
 
A SEAL action may be possible, but as a last resort. The pirates are short of food, water and hope, and negotiations may lead to a peaceful conclusion.

As for Peter Worthington's comment above re the traditional practice of hanging captured pirates from the yardarm, I have a short comment "hogwash." David Cordingly's Under the Black Flag, The Romance and Reality of Life Among the Pirates, which is considered a reliable source, has a long discussion of the trials and execution of pirates, especially in the era 1700-1730. There were about 2000 active pirates in the Caribbean and Eastern Seaboard of the British North American colonies at that time. A very large proportion were captured, tried on shore by properly constituted courts and executed. However, while these trials did not meet modern standards of due process, conviction and execution was not a foregone conclusion. A number of the accused were acquitted or, if convicted, received a lesser punishment.

Anyway, in the case of Winnipeg, it is my opinion after having read the DND press release, that the skiffs had not yet attacked the merchant ship. Now, whether the incident had reached the stage where an attack was imminent and anticipated, and thus pre-emption was justified under international law, |I was not there and I don't know.
 
Old sweat, lesser punishment in the 1700s would be considered hard time by today's standards
 
No doubt, but it still was a lesser punishment then. According to the above source, and this refers only to British courts, in the period in question (1700-1730) 550 men and two women were tried for piracy. Of these, 313 men were executed. The two women were convicted and sentenced to death, but the punishment was commuted as they were pregnant.

Back to the present, at least the world is taking some sort of action. It remains to be seen how effective it will be.
 
FBI hostage team joins standoff with pirates
PAUL KORING Globe and Mail Update April 9, 2009 at 9:53 AM EDT
Article Link

WASHINGTON — Gun-toting Somali pirates holding an American ship's captain hostage in a lifeboat were locked in a standoff today with a U.S. warship as a special FBI negotiating team was called in to try to end the high-seas drama.

The U.S. container ship Maersk Alabama remained nearby, its crew back in control after first losing a battle with Somali pirates, then managing to force them over the side after seizing one of the four attackers. Capt. Richard Phillips was bobbing in one of the Maersk Alabama's lifeboats, apparently a hostage but still alive.

Despite the enormous firepower of the guided-missile destroyer U.S.S. Bainbridge and its helicopters and naval aircraft circling overheard, a standoff continued between a handful of desperate armed men and the U.S. navy.

FBI spokesman Richard Kolko said a hostage rescue team is “fully engaged” with the military in strategizing ways to retrieve the ship's captain, although it was apparently working from a base in the United States, providing advice long distance.
More on link
 
Sounds like a show-down is brewing, other pirate ships with hostages to be used as bargaining chips are heading to the area.  More U.S. Navy ships also heading to thearea.  Select portions of the article:

Somali pirates want ransom, fear U.S. reprisals
Updated Fri. Apr. 10 2009 1:32 PM ET

CTV.ca News Staff

"U.S. Defense Department officials say Phillips jumped off the lifeboat, located nearly 500 kilometres off Somalia's Indian Ocean coast, and began swimming away. But he was quickly recaptured.

They do not believe the 53-year-old sea captain from Underhill, Vt., was harmed in the incident.

The pirates fired shots from an automatic weapon during the escape attempt, but it was not clear if the shots were aimed at Phillips or into the air."

"Pirate reinforcements

But it appears that the pirates have called for reinforcements as well.

"The pirates have summoned assistance -- skiffs and motherships are heading towards the area from the coast," an unnamed Nairobi-based diplomat told to AP on Friday. "We knew they were gathering yesterday."

Mohamed Samaw, a Somali resident who claims to own a "share" in a recently hijacked, British-owned ship, told AP that four foreign ships are headed for the lifeboat.

The pirates have 54 international hostages on board two of the ships, whom they will be using as bargaining chips. Samaw said a seized German cargo ship is among the ships moving towards the lifeboat.

Former FBI agent Jack Cloonan told AP that having other hijacked vessels arrive in the area "could complicate the negotiation strategy under way."

And the situation already is tense enough with the U.S. warships that are sailing towards the scene.

Abdi Sheikh, the Mogadishu Bureau Chief for Reuters, told CTV Newsnet that the pirates "are afraid to be bombed by the American warship."

The Maersk Alabama left the area on Thursday, protected by armed Navy SEALs who will ride with the cargo ship until it arrives at its destination port in Mombasa, Kenya, on Saturday night.

It was the sixth ship to be hit by pirates in the same week.

Because pirates have been able to repeatedly extort multimillion-dollar ransom fees from shipping companies, such attacks have become an ever-more common phenomenon.

Davis said pirates, like those involved in the current standoff, care little about the turmoil they cause for their hostages.

"They have no respect for anybody or anything else they just want the money to be able to change their own lives," he said.

With files from CTV Newsnet and The Associated Press"

More at: http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20090410/pirate_hostage_090410/20090410?hub=TopStories
 
Obama's dithering is making the USN look bad. The Bainbridge has a SEAL team onboard so they have the means to strike if they get permission.
 
I have been following this thread and the story on the MSM and one
thing strikes me ,the spirit of appeasement abroad in the World.The
maritime expert claiming violence is not a solution that we should
negotiate and pay up.I personally cannot think of better way to
convince pirates to continue in their chosen line of work and ensure
more to join them. The Captain of the Canadian should have blown
the mother ship out of the water IMHO, but of course that would not
have been a reasonable response,what would be a reasonable
response be might I ask?.
                          Regards
 
Back
Top