We were in Pet this summer and saw what you are talking about with regards to the demolition. reading the post by Muffin...it makes sense. although they are removing and back filling... they may be building elsewhere eventually for ease of congestion and parking and snow removal issues. We also saw some renovated Q's and they look really nice! One thing that caught my attention was basing projections of need on the realestate market...I know not much is moving here because of the economy, so basing a need for housing on the fact that no one is buying, and lots for sale wouldnt make sense.
as for the 'who should get debate'... IMHO
Firstly: I think they should build more apartments for singles/ young families of 2 who dont want to live in shacks. Now, im not saying this because they shouldnt have a house, but because an apartment would mean no grounds to keep up while contending with a busy schedual, more affordable then a house, more space and comfort then shacks but less unnecessary space to have to heat then a house.
Secondly: Married VS Single people.... i do side with Married with Children having first dibs. I have had a number of friends end up on wait lists and dealing with being separated because of wait-lists. Its hard on the children, and the wife (especially those with new babies). Thats one thing i havent seen mentioned in all the debate of who should get Q's. Yes, we deal with DH's being away on course, or overseas regularly, but when they are around, its nice to be with them.
Personally: from a wives perspective; living on base means more community support. The member is surrounded with people in 'the life' at work, they have some one to talk to about all things CF related. Most 'Civvies' dont understand our lifestyle, so being surrounded by neighbours who 'dont get it', or worse, dont support our troops, can be unbearable, which is another reason to live on base rather then buying. Not to mention the safety we feel living on Base when our DH's are away. Also, since there are a number of wives who dont drive , or their DH's take the car to work, being able to walk to places like the MFRC, rec centre, ect is also important.
Everyones points are valid, the CF is growing, many Q's need severe overhauls, and there is a need for more housing. Q's are more affordable then the going rent, not everyone can get a Mortgage, or are willing to buy, only to have to try and sell 2,3,5 years down the road, singles shouldnt have to be stuffed into shacks just because they are single, and families shouldnt have to be split up.