• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Canadian soldiers capture suspected Taliban fighters

This is nothing more than the ignorant, self obsessed press corps.  They are endlessly fascinated with one thing and one thing only: themselves.

Apologies to the dozen or so who do not fit the mold.

The rest of you (expletive deleted) ‘journalists’ are stealing oxygen from human beings.
 
I was amazed to pick up today's globe and mail.

What complete and utter bullshit. I was somewhat happy that Christine Blatchford was not involved in this - she seems to have a brain between her ears.

If anything the military did a service to the newspapers by giving them free legal advice.

If the military wanted to "supress" anything... well it would be supressed and we wouldn't be seeing any of this.

I believe it was on CBC, very early this morning, where they had some quotes from the actual journalist who was embeded. He seems to be very supportive of what the military did and understood their intention.

This really must have been a "make news" day, as there is also a story about how horrible the jails are in Kabul.

I really don't understand it, I'm always up for some good Harper bashing, but attacking not only legal but perfectly moral and compassionate Canadian actions in Afghanistan while trying to help rebuild the country....*anger*

I wonder what the press response would have been if the military just released the photo's without any advice...

MILITARY RELEASES PHOTO'S OF DETAINEE'S IN VIOLATION OF THEIR RIGHTS!


I suppose they think it would be better had we just patted the nice taliban on the back and sent them on their way.
 
I wonder what the press response would have been if the military just released the photo's without any advice...

It's a lose, lose situation.  Damned if you do, Damned if you don't.
 
Happily, the CBC report is much more rational...and one hopes this non-story is destined for the scrapheap...

http://www.cbc.ca/story/canada/national/2006/05/12/afghanistan05122006.html

Taliban suspects won't be harmed, Harper believes
Last Updated Fri, 12 May 2006 18:58:09 EDT
CBC News

Canada expects Afghan authorities will live up to their treaty obligations when Canadian soldiers hand over prisoners to them, Prime Minister Stephen Harper says.

Harper was commenting on news that Canadian troops had arrested 10 suspected insurgents in Afghanistan earlier this week, their biggest capture yet.

Harper was asked on Friday what assurances he has that those prisoners, who are now in the hands of Afghan security officials, won't be harmed.

"They're handing them over in accord with the treaty we've signed with the government of Afghanistan, to respect all of Canada's obligations under the Geneva Conventions. We expect the Afghan government to live up to those obligations, and have every reason to believe that they will.

"But, quite frankly let me say this," the prime minister added. "When our forces on the ground, taking on this terrible ex-regime, this terrible organization, when they capture people and when they make progress in their fight against the Taliban, I think this is something that all Canadians should celebrate."

Harper was also asked whether he thought photographs of the Afghan prisoners should have been suppressed. He said although he doesn't have an opinion on the pictures, he believes military operations are a matter of national security and it's up to Department of Defence officials to decide what information is released.

On Thursday, photographs were released of Canadian troops arresting 10 suspected Taliban members while escorting a convoy to Gumbad, north of Kandahar, where Canada maintains a forward operating base.

The Canadians were given a tip that a group was hiding in a compound.  Ten men were subsequently handed over to the Afghan National Police.

A photographer with Agence France-Presse was embedded with the unit and captured images of Canadian troops processing the detainees and taking them into custody.

A controversy arose when Canadian military authorities suggested the images may be a violation of the prisoners' rights under the Geneva Conventions.  Article 13 of the convention states: "Prisoners of war must at all time be protected, particularly against acts of violence or intimidation and against insults and public curiosity."

However the military later said it was up to the individual news organizations to decide if they wanted to publish the images.

In western Afghanistan on Friday, militants fired a rocket at a car carrying UNICEF workers to the city of Herat, killing two Afghans and seriously injuring a third. A United Nations' representative said the attack against the UN children agency was unusual and that he could not recall any UNICEF fatalities in the last four years in Afghanistan.
 
Kurhaus - they are PUC's not EPW's -- they do not fall into the catagories you listed.

PUC's previosuly where handed to the American's who then determine their status and potentially fly them to Gitmo.  I beleive currently they are turned over to the Afghan authorities (who are not nearly as nice as the Americans)

This is a non-event.
 
Protection against "public curiosity" means seizure of photographs?  There are definitely some people out there with a weak hold on reality.  That protection is there to restrain detaining powers from parading PWs through the streets and allowing the local population to come by the camps to taunt the detainees - no more good old-fashioned Roman triumphs.
 
big bad john said:
http://sympaticomsn.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20060503/afghan_prisoners_060511

Cdn soldiers capture suspected Taliban fighters
CTV.ca News

"Prisoners of war must at all time be protected, particularly against acts of violence or intimidation and against insults and public curiosity."

If only the other side would follow some set of basic rules as we all know what many Allied 'PWs' (non-cilivian) have had done to them in the past. 

Cheers,

Wes
 
Back
Top