Lets call a Spade a Spade here,
The Canadian Cellular coverage is a damn joke. I have deployed to Several Continents, and several Third World Countries. In turn I have learned several things;
1. Canadians wireless coverage is a Joke, you can not compare Canadian coverage to anywhere else in the world. Dont say "Suffield has horrible coverage, Libya must too," Chances are some farmer in Libya has better coverage then NDHQ recieves.
2. We pay way too effin much for the Sh!t service, as well as the even worst customer service.
3. Countries such as Afghanistan, Sierra Leone, Sudan, Congo, etc all have better coverage, and better QoS then Canadians do. I am in the middle one of Canadas largest cities, and I can barely get 3 bars of 3G coverage (i should be full LTE), on Canadas most popular provider. In Afghanistan on my BB, with Roshan (forget how it is spelt) I had a consistently full 3G coverage. In African countries, it was the same way, using a local SIM Card, I had tonnes of service, even in the boot F@$# boonies.
4. Every single time I deployed was for comms, comms would go down, we would either resort to satcomm (Iridium or Storm/BT2), or pull out the local cellular provider (which was by far a SH@#$ tonne cheaper). By no means did we discuss anything of a strategic or tactical nature, besides saying "we know, we are working on it" Yes, we wouldnt be able to provide secure, but with Iridium having a bird out, we could only provide secure 20hrs a day. (that is a "googleable" fact")
5. There are VERY few spots in the world we would deploy that does not have some sort of communications, if you are deployed to somewhere without it, Chances are JSR is right there, already set up or getting ready to be set up. OR something has been arranged and you are piggy backing off of someone else.
Just because you didnt have a fancy iTOY when you went through 20 years ago doesnt mean the guys coming through now shouldnt. If they want to have their cellphones, let em, I have been in the Mega with mine for CF purposes, there is horrible service and it drains the battery like none other.
Now saying that-
I do agree that it should definetly not cause a disturbance, or get in the way of training, or if required any correctional training, or team building experiences.
By the time a member succesfully passes basic, SQ etc and maybe even all glory PLQ at some point, they wont want to talk to the nagging wife as much.
Just because they wouldnt let you light a fire and produce smoke signals to talk to your loved ones while you were on course, doesnt mean the guys later need or deserve the same treatment, the mentality of "I had it this way, youll have it that way too" is toxic. A Military, like its country needs to grow, develop and change for the future.