- Status
- Reaction score
- 22,049
- Points
- 1,360
Guess, if your profile is accurate, then your salary is paid by the war machine.......hmmmm, do you have a mirror anywhere in your house?
Fractux, with regards to your question...
The Canadian Task Force currently operates under Coalition Force Command - Afghanistan (CFC-A), which is a coalition of several NATO and non-NATO nations taking on the task of securing and assisting development of the more volatile East and Southern Regions of the Afghanistan theatre of operations. NATO-ISAF is responsible for the other three Regions...well, two regions, West and North and a multi-national brigade in Kabul. Thus ISAF and CFC-A are complementary organizations, large numbers of NATO nations in each structure, but both also with non-NATO forces as well. In late fall, there are plans for CFC-A forces to fall under command of ISAF, once NATO completes so-called "Phase 3 expansion" to put in place the capability to command all non-Afghan military forces in Afghanistan. Regarding CFC-A, Canadian BGen Fraser is the Commander of CFC-A Regional Command (South) at this very moment. We also have a Canadian BGen in the headquarters command of Combined Joint Task Force 75 (CJTF-76), the operational-level command in-between the tactical-level RC(South) and the National-level CFC-A. We also have a team of Strategic Advisers embedded with the Afghan Government directly assisting reconstruction and National Development efforts. The effects of these various commands and groupings is that Canada has an especially influential effect on operations in Afghanistan, especially when considered in the context of working with our diplomatic and development Gov't of Canada partners also in Afghanistan. The Canadian provincial reconstruction team (PRT) in Khandahar works very closely with the Khandahari authorities and, through the links upwards through RC(South) to other coalition and Canadian assets, ensures that reconstructive efforts are as relevant to the people of Khandahar Province as possible. Is it a perfect system? No, but it certainly is one of the better working efforts that I've seen undertaken.
For the record, I have absolutely no issue with protest...it is a democratic right that I have served my country to protect, as did both of my grandfathers (RIP
) in WWII. What would go a long way in my books would be to see the protesters show a little more understanding of the issues than mere regurgitation of anti-American boilerplate text pulled of a website. It makes one wonder if they protest only the "safe" targets (Western countries) rather than being more focused on the cause vice symptoms of strife in the world.
I'm perhaps deluding myself into thinking that a reasonable number of these protesters might at least consider what those of us try to pass on from our experiences serving around the world. I've seen things first hand in Afghanistan, and contributed directly to making it a better place for Afghans to live. I try to pass on to those willing to listen my personal thoughts and views on the issue. My words are free, I expect anyone listening to exercise their right to agree or disagree with them. That's fine. I sleep soundly every night knowing I made a difference...not just talking about why someone should make a difference.
Cheers,
Duey
Fractux, with regards to your question...
The Canadian Task Force currently operates under Coalition Force Command - Afghanistan (CFC-A), which is a coalition of several NATO and non-NATO nations taking on the task of securing and assisting development of the more volatile East and Southern Regions of the Afghanistan theatre of operations. NATO-ISAF is responsible for the other three Regions...well, two regions, West and North and a multi-national brigade in Kabul. Thus ISAF and CFC-A are complementary organizations, large numbers of NATO nations in each structure, but both also with non-NATO forces as well. In late fall, there are plans for CFC-A forces to fall under command of ISAF, once NATO completes so-called "Phase 3 expansion" to put in place the capability to command all non-Afghan military forces in Afghanistan. Regarding CFC-A, Canadian BGen Fraser is the Commander of CFC-A Regional Command (South) at this very moment. We also have a Canadian BGen in the headquarters command of Combined Joint Task Force 75 (CJTF-76), the operational-level command in-between the tactical-level RC(South) and the National-level CFC-A. We also have a team of Strategic Advisers embedded with the Afghan Government directly assisting reconstruction and National Development efforts. The effects of these various commands and groupings is that Canada has an especially influential effect on operations in Afghanistan, especially when considered in the context of working with our diplomatic and development Gov't of Canada partners also in Afghanistan. The Canadian provincial reconstruction team (PRT) in Khandahar works very closely with the Khandahari authorities and, through the links upwards through RC(South) to other coalition and Canadian assets, ensures that reconstructive efforts are as relevant to the people of Khandahar Province as possible. Is it a perfect system? No, but it certainly is one of the better working efforts that I've seen undertaken.
For the record, I have absolutely no issue with protest...it is a democratic right that I have served my country to protect, as did both of my grandfathers (RIP
) in WWII. What would go a long way in my books would be to see the protesters show a little more understanding of the issues than mere regurgitation of anti-American boilerplate text pulled of a website. It makes one wonder if they protest only the "safe" targets (Western countries) rather than being more focused on the cause vice symptoms of strife in the world.I'm perhaps deluding myself into thinking that a reasonable number of these protesters might at least consider what those of us try to pass on from our experiences serving around the world. I've seen things first hand in Afghanistan, and contributed directly to making it a better place for Afghans to live. I try to pass on to those willing to listen my personal thoughts and views on the issue. My words are free, I expect anyone listening to exercise their right to agree or disagree with them. That's fine. I sleep soundly every night knowing I made a difference...not just talking about why someone should make a difference.
Cheers,
Duey
Infantry_wannabe
New Member
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 110
The earlier poster was right about RCMP training Iraqi police http://www.rcmp-grc.gc.ca/news/n_0401_e.htm. The idea that Canadian military personnel on exchange have served with the US in Iraq isn't new either. The PM even confirmed it recently saying "There have been a small number of Canadian military personnel embedded in American and allied units. That's been the case since the beginning of the war. Nothing has changed on that front." That's from a story by the dreaded CBC
http://www.cbc.ca/story/canada/national/2006/03/23/canadian_role060323.html (scroll down to part about the PM)
but this has been common knowledge since the Iraq war started.
Having said that, CANADA IS NOT AT WAR IN IRAQ. The Canadian government decided not to significantly participate in the war on Iraq. But international politics is a complicated thing. The US is our most important ally even if they do stupid things. To stop cooperating with their military (such as the example of the exchanges) would be a major blow to our alliances and to our national defence. RCMP officers training Iraqi police sounds like a good idea to me. We are not getting involved directly by sending troops to Iraq but are still trying to help Iraqis create a stable society. As for the Canadian companies involved in supplying the US military, what is the alternative? Banning all Canadian defence manufacturers from trading with the US? That sounds realistic, given our national interests. :
The war in Iraq was in my opinion a large mistake mixed with a touch of deliberate deception. I think 9/11 and the real fight against Al-Qaeda was used by the Bush administration to go into Iraq for wider strategic and economic reasons. However right some of these reasons might or might not have been, I think the conclusion is that the invasion should never have happened. There is still the humanitarian reason, but considering all the deaths which have resulted and the ongoing hopeless situation, I don't think it was worth it. I really hope that I turn out to be wrong about that...but I doubt it. To me, no WMD's=Massive Mistake.
As much as the anti-war protesters make me instinctively sick, I think it is important to have people who are willing to question what they are told. Obviously, if given a lawful command, that is not the job of the military (to protest against what they are told) but in a democracy it is vital for citizens. I just wish the protesters would think a little more clearly. As I implied in an earlier post, Iraq does not equal Afghanistan, the Oka crisis, the need to become a granola-eating, vegetable juice drinking vegan, or whatever other pet cause happens to be fashionable.
As much as I disagree with them, I do agree they have a right to protest. I am also free to express my own opinion: that the vegan anti-Afghanistan types are full of s---, that Bush is full of s---, and that we should support the troops in Afghanistan until hell freezes over if necessary. But then that's just my opinion.
http://www.cbc.ca/story/canada/national/2006/03/23/canadian_role060323.html (scroll down to part about the PM)
but this has been common knowledge since the Iraq war started.
Having said that, CANADA IS NOT AT WAR IN IRAQ. The Canadian government decided not to significantly participate in the war on Iraq. But international politics is a complicated thing. The US is our most important ally even if they do stupid things. To stop cooperating with their military (such as the example of the exchanges) would be a major blow to our alliances and to our national defence. RCMP officers training Iraqi police sounds like a good idea to me. We are not getting involved directly by sending troops to Iraq but are still trying to help Iraqis create a stable society. As for the Canadian companies involved in supplying the US military, what is the alternative? Banning all Canadian defence manufacturers from trading with the US? That sounds realistic, given our national interests. :
The war in Iraq was in my opinion a large mistake mixed with a touch of deliberate deception. I think 9/11 and the real fight against Al-Qaeda was used by the Bush administration to go into Iraq for wider strategic and economic reasons. However right some of these reasons might or might not have been, I think the conclusion is that the invasion should never have happened. There is still the humanitarian reason, but considering all the deaths which have resulted and the ongoing hopeless situation, I don't think it was worth it. I really hope that I turn out to be wrong about that...but I doubt it. To me, no WMD's=Massive Mistake.
As much as the anti-war protesters make me instinctively sick, I think it is important to have people who are willing to question what they are told. Obviously, if given a lawful command, that is not the job of the military (to protest against what they are told) but in a democracy it is vital for citizens. I just wish the protesters would think a little more clearly. As I implied in an earlier post, Iraq does not equal Afghanistan, the Oka crisis, the need to become a granola-eating, vegetable juice drinking vegan, or whatever other pet cause happens to be fashionable.
As much as I disagree with them, I do agree they have a right to protest. I am also free to express my own opinion: that the vegan anti-Afghanistan types are full of s---, that Bush is full of s---, and that we should support the troops in Afghanistan until hell freezes over if necessary. But then that's just my opinion.
Infantry-W
Though I don't agree with some of the points in your post = I appreciate your speaking your mind.
Looking back, I think the Bush administration did the right thing by invading Iraq. It will draw in terrorist-combatants for years to come and is an excellent staging area into other hot spots. The entire region was a terrorist accident waiting to happen. The intervention, at least now, is a controlled accident where the American driver is still in control of the military veh.
Most of the world is standing by watching and expecting the US to fail in Iraq. More than ever, I support the American position in Iraq. I also think president Bush has done a remarkable job. I also support small scale raids and other military operations into Iran, even if it's in violation of applicable laws, if it means Iran will have no nuclear capability.
Regards.
Though I don't agree with some of the points in your post = I appreciate your speaking your mind.
Looking back, I think the Bush administration did the right thing by invading Iraq. It will draw in terrorist-combatants for years to come and is an excellent staging area into other hot spots. The entire region was a terrorist accident waiting to happen. The intervention, at least now, is a controlled accident where the American driver is still in control of the military veh.
Most of the world is standing by watching and expecting the US to fail in Iraq. More than ever, I support the American position in Iraq. I also think president Bush has done a remarkable job. I also support small scale raids and other military operations into Iran, even if it's in violation of applicable laws, if it means Iran will have no nuclear capability.
Regards.
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 210
Protesters have the right to protest what they feel is wrongful intervention in the Middle East. Does that mean they should do protests instead of work or looking after the family? I for one don't participate in protests because they tend to be a waste of time, plus it looks bad from my point of view.
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 410
bbbb said:
Now there is a reason not to exercise my constitutional rights... because it looks bad. :
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 410
I think we always need to realize that there will be people in the left wing peace movement who will refuse to get the story straight for reasons of their own agenda.
When I lived in Vancouver in the early to late eighties I went to a church where the pastor was involved in the peace movement...those were the days they got thousands of people out for the the annual peace march.
He always used to pray for people in Nicaragua and Central America and was involved in groups that supported the movements down there that were anti-contra. I used to challenge him to think about the invasion of Afghanistan by the Soviet Union and wasn't that worthy of the same kind of effort. He never had a good answer for me and so tipped his hand that what it was really about was the "leftist agenda."
I wonder how he feels now that we are in Afghanistan?? (I could hazard a guess)
When I lived in Vancouver in the early to late eighties I went to a church where the pastor was involved in the peace movement...those were the days they got thousands of people out for the the annual peace march.
He always used to pray for people in Nicaragua and Central America and was involved in groups that supported the movements down there that were anti-contra. I used to challenge him to think about the invasion of Afghanistan by the Soviet Union and wasn't that worthy of the same kind of effort. He never had a good answer for me and so tipped his hand that what it was really about was the "leftist agenda."
I wonder how he feels now that we are in Afghanistan?? (I could hazard a guess)
ArmyRick
Army.ca Veteran
- Reaction score
- 2,350
- Points
- 1,010
I support the protestors right to moan and groan about everything military when we could proably be spending more money on welfare :
However I draw the line when the interfere with other people's rights. Such as physical blocking the military recruiting efforts at Universities (such as guelph last November). Any person who dares support the military or oh my, Steve Harper (he is the devil don't you know?) : Whatever.
What about the protest to stop the Nigerian woman from being excuted several years ago because she was pregnant and unwed (Sharia law)?
Where was the protest to stop the bloody killings in Rwanda? Or the protest of the UN to not get a pair and truly intervene?
Where is the protest for every dictator or murderous leader who kills innocent people?
Oh no, its much easier to have sit ins, protest proffessional military efforts and try to re-live the '60s here in a safe and secure enviroment (That so many around the world just do not have).
Well maybe some day they will understand that it takes force and sometimes lethal force to free the oppressed.......
However I draw the line when the interfere with other people's rights. Such as physical blocking the military recruiting efforts at Universities (such as guelph last November). Any person who dares support the military or oh my, Steve Harper (he is the devil don't you know?) :
Whatever.What about the protest to stop the Nigerian woman from being excuted several years ago because she was pregnant and unwed (Sharia law)?
Where was the protest to stop the bloody killings in Rwanda? Or the protest of the UN to not get a pair and truly intervene?
Where is the protest for every dictator or murderous leader who kills innocent people?
Oh no, its much easier to have sit ins, protest proffessional military efforts and try to re-live the '60s here in a safe and secure enviroment (That so many around the world just do not have).
Well maybe some day they will understand that it takes force and sometimes lethal force to free the oppressed.......
1
17thRecceSgt
Guest
as with everything else...I try to stay on the trace and make it to the objective...they are obstacles, and obstacles can be skirted, cleared, and then ya carry on...
If Danny Dope-Smoker and Patty Peace-lover want to protest...let them.
Just stay off my door step, and run if you start to burn the flag.
My advice to them is...if Afghanistan is such a WONDERFUL place to live...I will pay for their one-way plane ticket. Don't forget to write now!
If Danny Dope-Smoker and Patty Peace-lover want to protest...let them.
Just stay off my door step, and run if you start to burn the flag.
My advice to them is...if Afghanistan is such a WONDERFUL place to live...I will pay for their one-way plane ticket. Don't forget to write now!
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 210
THAT's TO GuessGuess said:
( USE IT PROPERLY ) You talk about our forefathers, they whould roll over in their grave's to heir you, I'am glad you have to pay for your higher school, what a wast of taxpayer's money. You left wing crack pot, sitting here in a secure enviroment, on the gravy train, biting the hand that feed you!!!!!! PROTESTING for the hell of it, it's cool !! let's being the kid's they have face painting, ( WE ARE AT WAR !!!! ).
If you think Afghanistan is so great, move there, put your kid's in school, Better yet you can talk in the village's, they think like you. ( you'd last 1 hr at best ).
Respect if you had some, you wouldn't be here, we are still morning our dead, shithead, but you dodn't get it.!!!!
I'am glad the government doesn't think like you, we would be like the NAZT'S,in your hafe backed world.
S*** for brains.
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 410
hmmm... you realize that the protests were over two months ago, right? This thread is stale by atleast one month.
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 210
scoutfinch said:
what about
last week in Wenp.
All I have been reading the last few days, in this form is all the protesting for people like Guess, Pike & the one that got kicked out, this is not the form for that, we need surport , not kicked when down.
GK .Dundas
Army.ca Veteran
- Reaction score
- 1,634
- Points
- 960
*sigh* I'll say it if nobody else will, learn to read ( and write too! For gods' sake!)Just what protesters are you protesting against here?bilton090 said:
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 410
hmmmm... keep reading. There is an entire thread discussing the feeble Wpg protests... in fact, that thread has moved on to post ex critiques so you probably shouldn't start ranting and raving about protestors on that thread either.
George Wallace
Army.ca Dinosaur
- Reaction score
- 184
- Points
- 710
I'd recommend staying off those 'corner drugs'. They hinder making coherent posts.
1
17thRecceSgt
Guest
HA HA HA ok that made my day...
:rofl:
:rofl:
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 210
Will someone please tell this person...that the chances of getting any support for protesting against such things is most likely not going to occur here and better yet...to be taken remotely seriously...dear god there is spell check if nothing else...lmao rotfl
Good one George!!!
HL
Good one George!!!
HL
A
aesop081
Guest
I'm still looking for "Wenp" 
- Status
Similar threads
