- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 110
Sorry if this has been done; I was just talking about this with a friend yesterday, he believes we would have won.
Nielsen_Noetic said:I agree T.I.M it does depend on a lot of thing's, I also agree that the U.S.S.R would have eventually prevailed over Germany. I was posing the question with the premise that material support would have continued.
You must all keep in mind as well though that Canada had quite few troops being held back in Canada as well as nearly a million troops in Britain doing nothing but training for a little over two years. Not to mention the large amount of supplies coming out of Canada.
Oh and presume the U.S. did go to war with Japan.
Nielsen_Noetic said:I regress; your right regarding the statistics in Great Britain and those regarding our active troop strength during the war I must have meant a million troops in the entire forces. I will however back my statement that we had many troops being held back in Canada. For numerous reasons not least of which being we were holding basically every German prisoner coming out of the western theater.
-Hutch- said:i think the allies would of won the war but it would of taken years and years longer.
i know the American went through some intense fighting and had many casualties ( band of brothers for example) but the allies could of done it. although i am very happy the Americans did join in because they assisted the allies in such a large way that it ended the war so much faster.
though I still hold to the idea that Russia would have eventually won the war
-Hutch- said:i think the allies would of won the war but it would of taken years and years longer.
i know the American went through some intense fighting and had many casualties ( band of brothers for example) but the allies could of done it. although i am very happy the Americans did join in because they assisted the allies in such a large way that it ended the war so much faster.