• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Swiss Army Worries About Thousands Of Recruits Unfit For Service

Blackadder1916

Army.ca Fixture
Reaction score
2,767
Points
1,160
Swiss Army Worries About Thousands Of Recruits Unfit For Service
http://www.24heures.ch/pages/home/24_heures/english_corner/news/news_detail/(contenu)/45350
Two-thirds of young Swiss men called up last year were ineligible for duty, according to the recently released results of aptitude tests. Soldiers living in the countryside are in better shape than those from urban areas.

Military service is obligatory for young Swiss men, but only 64 per cent of recruits last year were fit for service, a trend that worries top army brass. At the 2006 recruitment sessions, only 24,100 out of 37,400 candidates passed the test to be eligible for the military service.

The difference in eligibility between those living in urban and rural areas is striking. In the rural Swiss-German canton of Appenzell, in the eastern part of Switzerland, more than eight out of 10 recruits passed the test, the highest rate of the country. By contrast, the share of successful recruits in the canton of Geneva fell below the national average, with only 57.26 per cent, while in Jura barely more than one in two candidates passed muster, the worst rate in the country.

These figures provide a revealing overview of the medical state of young Swiss people. Ultimately, 25 per cent of recruits are neither eligible for military service nor for community service (required as an alternative to army duty). Half of the rejected recruits have psychological difficulties. The other half have medical problems, detected during the recruitment tests, such as orthopedic symptoms, asthma and obesity.

 
Must be all that yummy swiss chocolate mmmmmmm!!

Over here it's the burger and fry addiction and the couch potato syndrome.  ;D
 
I really don't think it's as bad as they think it is, remember they are taking their data from an entire country's population of young men. If you put all of Canada's young men in the application process I would wager that the pass rate would be about 60%. Think how many fail the application process currently for the CF, and those people are volunteering to sign up. It's not hard to fail an aptitiude test if you have no desire to serve.
 
AlphaCharlie said:
It's not hard to fail an aptitiude test if you have no desire to serve.

Agreed...especially when "Half of the rejected recruits have psychological difficulties".
 
......remember they are taking their data from an entire country's population of young men.  ..... It's not hard to fail an aptitiude test if you have no desire to serve.
  I think their concern is not just that they find enough recruits for the Swiss army.  After all there have been moves in Switzerland over the past couple of decades to not only reduce the size of the military, but (I think) they may even have had a referendum proposing to eliminate it totally (it didn't pass).  According to their current laws if you do not complete military service, you are required to do "civil service" and pay a surcharge on your taxes.  I'm not sure if the tax surcharge applies if you are unable to perform "any" service.  From what I understand, they are having increasing problems with people deliberately trying to avoid any form of national service.
 
I spent a night bending an elbow with a couple of recently released Swiss troops last spring,

blackadder1916 said:
   I'm not sure if the tax surcharge applies if you are unable to perform "any" service. 

It depends on the reason they can't perform...I know one fellow mentioned that failing the medical for avoidable reasons (such as non-medical fitness issues or prior drug use) was NOT an acceptable excuse.

DF
 
This is perhaps one of those that they wish had been found unfit for military service

Gunman Uses Army Rifle In Hotel Shooting
http://www.nzz.ch/2007/04/14/eng/article7714027.html
14. April 2007, Swissinfo

A 26:year:old Swiss has killed one man and injured four others, one critically, after opening fire with his army assault rifle in a Swiss hotel.

The latest in a series of fatalities involving army weapons ? which all able:bodied Swiss men have to keep at home with ammunition ? will add fuel to the heated political debate over reforming the country's gun laws.

The man was subdued and arrested by police after the shooting on Thursday evening in the northern city of Baden, canton Aargau.

Police said the gunman, who worked in a bank in Zurich, entered the La Capella hotel and opened fire on two boys, one 15 and one 16, who were sitting in the hotel's restaurant with their parents.

The 16:year:old was still reported to be in a critical condition with at least two stomach wounds on Saturday. The 15:year:old was hit in the upper arm and grazed on his abdomen and is said to be out of danger.

The gunman then aimed at the people at the bar. A 71:year:old man died immediately from four shots to the head. A 59:year:old man suffered graze wounds to his stomach and upper arm, and another man, aged 50, admitted himself to hospital with a stomach wound.

The gunman, who like all his victims was from Baden, only stopped shooting when he had used up all 20 shots in the magazine of his military rifle.

"It was fortunate that we didn't have an even greater catastrophe and that the man didn't have more than the one magazine," said Urs Winzenried, head of Aargau cantonal police.

Winzenried said it was not immediately clear what had caused the man to start shooting.

Tradition

The latest in a series of shootings involving army weapons ? in March a man shot his girlfriend in southeastern Switzerland ? will undoubtedly be picked up by political parties who are demanding reforms to Switzerland's gun laws.

All able:bodied Swiss men aged 20:30 are conscripted for about three months and issued with a rifle, to be used only in the event of an alert.

After initial training, conscripts are required to do three or four weeks of army service a year until they have served a total of 260 days or reached the age of 34. Throughout this time they keep their rifles and 50 rounds of ammunition at home.

On Friday various organisations and centre:left parties said they would announce on May 25 whether they would launch a people's initiative to ban such weapons in households.

At the end of March parliament refused to tighten the gun law, including having a central arms register.

Although anti:gun arguments and demands could gain majority support among voters, especially women and younger people, they have a tough time in parliament where they face a formidable gun lobby, which puts pressure on the centre:right parties in particular.

Bad record

Switzerland has an unenviable record when it comes to murders involving army weapons.

Five years ago Switzerland was shocked when a gunman shot and killed 14 people in Zug's cantonal parliament with his army rifle, before turning the gun on himself.

In the first half of 2006 there were at least six incidents where a man shot his wife or partner before turning the gun on himself. In a highly publicised case the husband of former women's ski champion Corinne Rey:Bellet killed her and her brother and seriously injured her mother with his army pistol before killing himself.

In September 2006 the government said family tragedies and suicides were not valid reasons to stop soldiers from keeping their army weapons at home.

Swiss Defence Minister Samuel Schmid, a member of the rightwing Swiss People's Party, argued that Switzerland's militia army needed to be able to mobilise rapidly, "for example to protect airports and railway stations".
 
Back
Top