I will bow to KevinB, as he probably has put the Hatch ones to much greater abuse than me.
But for me, the hatch have serve me well. Stiching is not fantastic, but has not come undone. I like that it shields me form cold metal parts, without cutting much of the feel. Grip is good too. Fits nice and snug, not much stretching.
Take into consideration that I put mine throught only minor use. Range, week end field ex, driving and other misc light duty.
No one should EVER consider these for street motorcycle use. They will shield your hands from the wind, thats about it.
I have the shorty operators one.