Sure, we're always going to have those people that can't make the standard. By all means C&P them. But we have to think as an institution, how do we enable them to get fitter? You put in your stats and it dumps you a fitness program, along with how to do all the exercises. You want these people to get fit but if they haven't been in a gym before is pretty imposing. 10 years in the CF and I've never been taken around a weight room or shown a fitness program other than Monday run, tuesday circuit, wednesday run, thursday ruck and friday sports. That's not a PT program, that's lip service. You're right, we don't need elite athletes, but we demand a high level of fitness. So here comes this program offering tools to help people break free of the "exempt expres" level and really start to excel and better themselves. How this is a bad thing I don't know.
Sure, we may have some people with a fitness problem in the CF, but I don't know how you can be against something that's enabling people who want to change to start that change. If they don't want to change than here's the door. I'd rather dump a little bit of cash into a website than pay for all the obesity related diseases/injuries or the wasted cost of a 15 year soldier who's on C&P because they let themselves go and no one gave them a hand other than "shape up or ship out".