- Reaction score
- 5,966
- Points
- 1,260
I think Lorne Gunther, in today's National Post at: http://www.canada.com/national/nationalpost/news/comment/story.html?id=30e79d4b-6efe-4048-84d4-c3a7e52885af just about sums it up as far as I am concerned. He has identified the symptoms and the underlying cause ...
Emphasis added
Emphasis added
We have the heart but we can't deliver it
Lorne Gunter
National Post
January 17, 2005
Saturday, while watching a domestic cable news network, I heard my umpteenth Canadian official/celebrity/aid worker piously tout the fact that Canada is giving more to tsunami relief than the United States.
It's not true, for one thing. If you add up the value of their aid, plus the cost of the aircraft carrier, relief ships, transport planes, squadrons of helicopters and all the personnel needed to man them, fuel needed to run them and ferry food and water to tsunami victims, the Americans' contribution is unsurpassed in the world.
As if compassion were a competition determined by monetary yardsticks and calculators anyway.
Besides, I am always dubious of Liberal accounting.
Our perpetually governing party is famous for back-loading its pledges, giving comparatively small amounts up front, while promising much larger sums in the later years of multi-year programs. This enables them to take credit for amazing generosity now, then find reasons not to come up with the full figure later when the public has forgotten about the commitment.
But, like I said, compassion cannot be written in ledger books. So both Canadians and Canadian governments -- federal and provincial -- deserve credit for the outpouring of their sympathy and kindness, whatever the final totals are.
But hearing Saturday's smug Canadian -- a rocker who recently performed in a tsunami relief concert -- I was reminded of a sad story once told to me by a Christian missionary, and why we have no business being self-righteous.
The missionary had been working in East Africa in the 1980s when one of the region's infamous droughts took hold. Periodically, the Horn of Africa experiences horrendous droughts, the result of either weather or Marxist land reforms, or both.
The aid worker said he was initially touched -- overwhelmed actually -- by the developed world's concern and its torrent of supplies. Governments, private charities and individuals sent mounds of relief.
Then my friend grew increasingly frustrated. Little of the aid got to the victims. What wasn't stolen by unscrupulous government officials for resale, the proceeds from which found their way into numbered accounts, often rotted on the dock or in warehouses. There was no way to get it to those who needed it.
In many places, there was no order. Bandits and rebels hijacked conveys and helped themselves to the contents at the business ends of AK-47s.
Where there was sufficient peace, insufficient infrastructure existed to transport the goodwill offerings of the developed world to the Third World victims of famine.
There is currently a threat of the same thing happening in the tsunami-ravaged regions. The Los Angeles Times reported last weekend: "Relief workers say there are enough food and supplies coming in to meet the basic needs of tsunami victims. Yet many still go wanting." As Michael Elmquist, head of the UN humanitarian affairs office in Indonesia, told ABC News, "It is difficult to get the supplies out (to many regions of Aceh, the hardest hit province in Indonesia). There are no roads, no telephones, no infrastructure of any kind."
Were it not for the American and Australian militaries, Mr. Elmquist explained, "there would be no way to avoid another disaster."
The Australians have 900 troops in the area, plus a full field hospital, helicopters, landing craft capable of delivering supplies to remote beaches and a company of army engineers to rebuild power and water supplies.
So it is all well and good for pompous Canadian pop musicians to tut-tut American miserliness. But our monetary compassion as a nation won't amount to much unless some other nation -- which hasn't starved its military into virtual inoperability over the last three decades -- agrees to deliver the fruits of our generosity in our stead.
Yes, our 200-strong Canadian Forces Disaster Assistance Response Team is doing a superb job in Sri Lanka, ferrying supplies to survivors and the wounded and ill to medical attention. But theirs is a much smaller direct, physical contribution than a country our size, with our resources, could have made if two generations of Liberal politicians hadn't contemptuously suffocated our armed forces.
The anti-military attitude of Canadian nationalists has always astounded me. Just how did they think we were going to preserve our sovereignty, protect our national interests, project our values and keep the international peace without a strong military? By singing John Lennon songs, visualizing world peace, droning on endlessly about "soft power" and badgering the Americans to be more multilateral?
Canada has become a finger-pointer and a cheque-writer in international affairs, not a sleeve-roller. We've done much to be proud of in tsunami relief, but we could have done so much more. And there is a chance much of our well-intentioned assistance will come to naught because, as a nation, we no longer have the capacity to carry our kindness the last, most difficult steps.
© National Post 2005