I wonder if each were thinking of where they lived and the area they worked.
A pair of gloves for Operations in BC coastal is different then a pair of gloves for BC mountain, different for Alberta prairies, different for Manitoba Winters, along with Ontario and Eastern Canada requirements much different then summer time in each area. Or task, driving, shooting, digging etc.
I use to wear one of 4 types of gloves for work depending on the weather, job required/ dexterity etc.
While in the Army I would wear the black Deu gloves if needed in the field. They gave a bit of protection from the Scottish broom and concertina wire. Sometimes wore the green nit ones if my hands were chilly or I couldn't put my hands in my pockets.
Other wise I rarely wore gloves
Some guys liked the flight gloves.
In the Airforce I wore flight gloves in the summer during checks, and black DEU gloves in the winter.