Reproduced under the fair dealings act.
http://cnews.canoe.ca/CNEWS/Law/2006/08/04/1719803-cp.html
Mountie issued gag order over Mayerthorpe inquiry
By SCOTT SUTHERLAND
VICTORIA (CP) - A group representing front-line police officers in British Columbia says one of its members has received a gag order from RCMP brass.
The B.C. Federation of Police Officers says Const. Rob Creasser did a radio interview last month suggesting it's taking too long for answers into what happened when four officers were gunned down last year in Alberta.
The interview, with a Kamloops radio station, followed the July killings of a pair of Saskatchewan RCMP officers.
Creasser also questioned on air whether there are enough officers on the force, saying municipal departments have more resources.
Don McKenzie, president of the federation, said that after the interview, Creasser was issued an order to stop commenting in public.
"Here's an individual, a police officer, sworn to protect the public, to be honest and tell the truth, being punished for just that," said McKenzie, a police detective in Abbottsford.
"He drew attention to some manpower shortage issues within the RCMP as well as questioned why there hadn't been anything given to front-line police officers in the province regarding the tragedy in Mayerthorpe."
The federation quoted from the superintendent's order which cited a section of the RCMP Act stating: "A member shall not publicly criticize, ridicule, petition, or complain about the administration, operation, objective or policies of the force."
The order also said the constable's comments are "under review and may result in further investigation."
The RCMP have faced criticism from several directions over the length of time it's taking for the results of their Mayerthorpe inquiry to become public.
After the two Mounties were killed in Spiritwood, Sask., Denis Allchurch, the MLA for the community demanded: "What have we learned or done since that, because it has happened right here in this small community?"
An RCMP spokesman was not aware of the specific order issued to Creasser, but confirmed the regulation, known as Section 41.
"We do not have permission, as members of the force, to publicly criticize the RCMP or the government, or ridicule policies, criticize courts," said Cpl. Tom Seaman. "We're not supposed to and we're not allowed to do that."
He said there are proper channels for officers to voice their concerns internally.
"To take it externally and to go public with those concerns, as you can see, is against regulations," said Seaman.
McKenzie said his group wants to protect the rights of individual officers within the RCMP to speak their mind, adding that the RCMP Act does not supersede the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
"They're muzzling their own members from speaking out when they see something wrong or trying to protect their fellow officers."
He said the federation's concern is that this gag order - coupled with what he called a recent RCMP directive to media relations officers to limit the information they release to reporters - amounts to a "muzzling" of police that may help erode public trust.
Seaman rejects that.
"Our surveys show the public trust level remains very high with communities we serve. We haven't seen anything like that at all," he insisted.
"We are not muzzling our communication officers at all."
Seaman said news reports earlier this week about the media relations directive were referring to a "discussionary paper" that has taken more than 18 months to compile.
The paper suggested the RCMP refrain from speaking too much to the media in an effort to cut back on news reports about crime, which the paper suggests heighten public anxiety.
But Seaman said the RCMP has been successful recently in improving communications.
McKenzie and the federation of police officers disagree.
"I think recently the RCMP have come under fire for some of their practices from a managerial point of view," McKenzie said.
"They are trying to control information to the public. It's all about spinning, about spin-doctoring that is, and making sure the image of the RCMP is not tarnished with fact."
Creasser, vice-president of the B.C. Mounted Police Professional Association, was unavailable for comment.