• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Emergency Response Times

winds_13 said:
Mariomike, is it normal for the service wait time in Ottawa during such staffing shortages to be over 2 hours and for ambulances to be dispatched from cities about 170km away? Or is this an abnormal occurence resulting from a greater than usual staffing shortage?
Click to expand...

I just know what was reported,

For many years, Ottawa has struggled with having no ambulances free to send to a call, mainly because paramedics are tied up at hospital emergency rooms waiting to transfer patients to hospital staff.
Click to expand...

It's not the exception, but the norm.
Click to expand...
 
mariomike said:
I wouldn't get hysterical over it. Sounds like it happens twice a day, every day, in Ottawa.
Click to expand...

I know both Lanark and Renfrew have Paramedics routinely respond into Ottawa. Particularly from immediately adjacent communities like Almonte, Arnprior, CP etc.
 
Bluebulldog said:
I know both Lanark and Renfrew have Paramedics routinely respond into Ottawa. Particularly from immediately adjacent communities like Almonte, Arnprior, CP etc.
Click to expand...

Sounds like "Level Zero" is routine in Ottawa, and has been for a long time.
 
No surprise.

The "Do more, with less" mentality.

As a rural resident just outside Ottawa, the former Township of West Carleton ( where I Live in Constance Bay), has two cruisers available at any given time, over a huge geographical area, average response time for Police and EMS is typically 20-25mins. Ironically, Fire, which is 100% volunteer usually has a greater response time, due to there being a number of stations at strategic points.

....still paying lots of $$ to the City of Ottawa tax levy however.
 
22 mins for a pri one response is nuts. Should be half that. And that’s taking into account the phone call. There may be a difference in how they score the time but NYPD is between 8 and 10. Big difference organizationally- not really comparable beyond the fact they are huge cities but Toronto needs to reorganize itself. 22 mins to me means you may as well take the lights off the cars.

As an aside the new TPS uniforms look comfortable but they look awful.
 
Bluebulldog said:
No surprise.

The "Do more, with less" mentality.

As a rural resident just outside Ottawa, the former Township of West Carleton ( where I Live in Constance Bay), has two cruisers available at any given time, over a huge geographical area, average response time for Police and EMS is typically 20-25mins. Ironically, Fire, which is 100% volunteer usually has a greater response time, due to there being a number of stations at strategic points.

....still paying lots of $$ to the City of Ottawa tax levy however.
Click to expand...

Hah, no it doesn’t. West Division may have two cars assigned to your sector, meaning they’ll drift back that way if nothing priority is going on, but don’t think for a second they’re sitting there free to cover Constance Bay and Dunrobin if there’s something serious in Kanata or Stittsville that needs units. I would bet that most of the time there are no cars at all close to you. Most of the time there aren’t serious calls out there, so that’s where deployments get risk managed.
 
brihard said:
Hah, no it doesn’t. West Division may have two cars assigned to your sector, meaning they’ll drift back that way if nothing priority is going on, but don’t think for a second they’re sitting there free to cover Constance Bay and Dunrobin if there’s something serious in Kanata or Stittsville that needs units. I would bet that most of the time there are no cars at all close to you. Most of the time there aren’t serious calls out there, so that’s where deployments get risk managed.
Click to expand...
There was a provincial capital west of Ontario that had two police officers on for the whole city for an hour every Sunday morning and Monday morning 4-5am back in 2009-2010. Those were awkward calls lol
 
brihard said:
Hah, no it doesn’t. West Division may have two cars assigned to your sector, meaning they’ll drift back that way if nothing priority is going on, but don’t think for a second they’re sitting there free to cover Constance Bay and Dunrobin if there’s something serious in Kanata or Stittsville that needs units. I would bet that most of the time there are no cars at all close to you. Most of the time there aren’t serious calls out there, so that’s where deployments get risk managed.
Click to expand...
Yeah, no illusions on this end.
 
Booter said:
Toronto needs to reorganize itself. 22 mins to me means you may as well take the lights off the cars.
Click to expand...

Regarding Response Times in Toronto.

From the City of Toronto Paramedic Service 2023 Operating Budget:

In 2022, Response Time at the 90th percentile was 14 minutes 11 seconds.

Mental health emergency calls increased by 86% since 2015.

Since 2015, a 153% increase in opiod OD's.

882% increase in WSIB costs 2013 - 2021.
 
I wonder what the cost per person, adjusted for todays values, the various emergency services cost, like- what did Toronto spend on EMS and police in 1983, adjusted, and then what do they spend today.

Just for comparison sake. I know that the medical side has seen dramatic increases in qualifications, pressure, and paperwork as well as professional skills upkeep. So have the police. I wonder if the money is keeping up with the creeping demand.

I suspect it doesn’t. I manage quite a bit of money- and the system predicted costs haven’t kept up with the increase in costs very well even in the last five years. So while there are modest increases to an astronomical amount of money- the power of the money is decreasing faster than those increases. So while it looks like a community is spending more- the services ability to generate return is diminished slightly. Year after year.

So less officers have less time and more commitments and the modest money increases ( to what is a healthy portion of a communities budget) actually continually fund a slight deficit.
 
brihard said:
That’s less than a quarter of the square mileage of the city of Ottawa. Absolutely massive rural catchment.
Click to expand...
When I joined fire out here, I was shown a map basically showing 5 other Canadian municipalities within Ottawas borders.
 
That's one way to deal with car thieves.

Matt Gurney: The police have given up. They've surrendered​

“To prevent the possibility of being attacked in your home, leave your fobs by your front door. Because they’re breaking into your homes to steal your car. They don’t want anything else. A lot of them that [the police] are arresting have guns on them. And they’re not toy guns. They’re real guns. They’re loaded.”
Click to expand...
 
Jarnhamar said:
That's one way to deal with car thieves.

Matt Gurney: The police have given up. They've surrendered​

Click to expand...
That's why I just leave mine running in the driveway...protects my family with the bonus of driving my climate warrior neighbours crazy!

Bill Hader Omg GIF by Saturday Night Live
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

mariomike
Billing
Replies
7
Views
4K
mariomike
mariomike
Blackadder1916
    • Like
    • Insightful
What will medicine on the battlefield look like?
Replies
9
Views
685
KevinB
KevinB
mariomike
Communicable Disease Management
Replies
0
Views
3K
mariomike
mariomike
G
    • Like
Leave Pass Response Time
2
Replies
33
Views
15K
CountDC
CountDC
daftandbarmy
Jonathan Pedneault resigns from Green Party, leaving Elizabeth May as sole leader
Replies
11
Views
1K
Loachman
L
Back
Top